September 11, 2009 at 7:45 PM #174020
I just needed to rant about something that I have seen more and more lately – well, ever since I transitioned from my 8830 to my 9630 (aka Tour)… It appears that more and more frequently as BlackBerry third-party application developers attempt to code around API limitations, they stomp upon some other capability that is built into the RIM OS or bundled RIM applications. What especially appears to be annoying is the fact that version to version anomalies are becoming more and more prevalent.
RIM has made an effort in the last few months to release tools such as the Developer Issue Tracker but most resolutions just tell you that it has been fixed in future OS versions. For example, a bug we submitted about the OS 4.6 browser was resolved by saying it was fixed in OS 4.7.
Since the middle of July, I have stumbled upon the following bugs, both of which took significant time to troubleshoot:
1. Anagram [http://getanagram.com/blackberry]: Anagram v0.9.9 innocently invoked a limitation within the Address Book app that would not allow contacts without a company name but NO first or last name to be edited on the device and be synced back to Outlook. I was able to identify Anagram as the culprit based upon exceptions logged to the device log. Once brought to the developer’s attention, this was resolved with a “silent” release of Anagram 0.9.10 – Anagram 1.0 is in the works.
2. Several third-party apps – PodTrapper [http://versatilemonkey.com], RSA SecurID Token for BlackBerry [http://rsa.com], and SmrtGuard [http://SmrtGuard.com] (there may be more) – that apparently register a handler for the ‘text/xml’ type break the built-in RIM Messages app as far as displaying “some” HTML or multi-part e-mail messages with attachments. The messages show an “attachment” of type text/plain that cannot be viewed or displayed on the device in addition to the “legitimate” attachments. SmrtGuard caused this problem for me, which has taken several weeks for me to narrow down as I could not easily identify consistent cases where is did or did not occur. PodTrapper has since issued a beta version of their software that addresses the issue, but as far as I know, the other two developers are still investigating the issue (SmrtGuard hopes to release an update by week’s end! J). Some BlackBerry community forum posts that I found that discuss this issue are:
A user’s first reaction is that these are obviously OS issues, but neither the carriers nor RIM are able to reproduce the problems – it is let to the user to attempt to determine the root cause. I find it interesting that RIM’s own forum does not identify the cause of the problem not the interim work-around (I have since replied to the post! http://mobileutil.com]. The app is unable to extract a phone number from the Call Log for reminders on this particular device.
- Matthias Marquardt, developer of FileScout, GPSLogger, and GPSsies Connect [http://emacberry.com], is constantly wrestling with API limitations and OS version-specific bugs. The latest being that “For some reason, the layout manager does not support horizontal & vertical scrolling within a TextField for the touch screen [Storm-specific] at the same time (looks like a bug in the OS) … I tried all my best to get around this flaw but I was not successful yet – my apologies for this inconvenience.” Issues such as this continue to frustrate Matthias in his attempt to expand the capabilities of his apps even further. A couple more of his “favorites” are:
- “One that is IMHO way more funny is the ProgressBar implementation – where you specify MIN and MAX value [max progress value can be Integer.MAX] – but when they calculate the percentage value they multiply the current value with 100 and then divide by the MAX value (in order to get the percentage value). The Problem is, when the current value get’s in an area of Integer.MAX/100 then it will happen, that the the Integer gets an overflow. In Java this will result in a negative value. This will cause the “default progress bar” to jump from a positive percentage value to something negative… increasing become zero, continue increasing and then instantly fall back to a negative value again. This will repeat for some time. This is a problem (Integer overflow) that each Java developer will learn in the first year of developing software… This error is in ALL 4.x OS!!!” [http://supportforums.blackberry.com/rim/board/message?board.id=java_dev&thread.id=27138]
- “Bold & Storm have inverted altitude values from the GPS-Antenna…” This one now affects the Tour, too!
Ronen HalevyKeymasterPosts: 2,906
Well said Tom!September 11, 2009 at 9:44 PM #181009
Here’s a good one for you. Weatherbug was built apparently for the Storm and then ported to other devices. They replace the “menu” invoked by the BlackBerry button with one of their own design. This design works well enough on a touch screen but is frustrating as h3ll on the Tour, and exacerbated by the more apps you have on your device that integrate into the menu.
Verizon Bold 9930 work
Verizon Droid Bionic playSeptember 12, 2009 at 2:10 AM #181010
Wow! what a well written article. I am a new BlackBerry consumer [addict]. I started with the 8330 and recently am owner of the 9630. I passed the Curve over to my wife and now she talks to me while looking at her Blackberry screen. What I have found frustrating is to think that just because a site that sells apps says an app will work on the Tour does not mean it will. When the app does not work and I contact the seller’s support, days later they shoot me back an email with the developers support link and then it is search and read for a fix or work- around. It feels like I just paid for a Beta without the benefit of a Bug link. I have since learned to read all the forums to see if an app works on the tour and then when possible go to the developer site to purchase it. Again, Tom, Thanks for a great article.September 13, 2009 at 6:43 PM #181011
Luis MerlosModeratorPosts: 431
Specially if you are buying from a store like mobihand the developer usually controls what info it relates to the user about the app, but usually mobihand is pretty good at working with people who buy an app does not work on your device.September 17, 2009 at 1:26 PM #181012
Here is more of an explanation of what is going on with #2 above posted by someone on CrackBerry: http://forums.crackberry.com/f132/text-attachment-243433/index3.html#post3608499September 18, 2009 at 3:38 PM #181013
Here is a “classic” example! BeejiveIM 1.96 Beta introduces integration with the Messages Inbox as one of their new features. This did not appear to work on my 9630 (aka Tour) with OS v126.96.36.199. I found the following entry in the BeejiveIM application log:
08:43:00.882 [e] Error while regisntering Beejive IM application for
I read in a forum that the issue appeared to be related to the installation of BlackBerry® App World on the same device. Notice the change after App World is uninstalled (message in the same point in the BeejiveIM log):
11:17:39.972 inbox folder registered..[email protected]8de
At this point, Messages Inbox integration works! Does this mean that RIM’s own app has broken their own API?!? Sure looks like it to me! https://community.emc.com/thread/4228 . Of course, no indication as to how long it will be for a fix to be identified…
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.