I personally recommend Seidio for hard cases. They fit well and are very durable.
I've only really bought the "surface" make, so I can't comment on the rugged, or active one.
The surface case on my torch is incredible. I had a case mate one on and it seemed to amplify the wobble at the bottom of my phone whenever I needed to press the trackpad.
The Seidio fits snug, and actually reduces the wobble. Weird.
I only wish they would provide a screen protector with it.
