BerryReview.com - BlackBerry News and Reviews
Forgot? | Register
Shop The BerryReview Store

Judge Rules Royalties for Public Performances of Ringtones is Sham

2 Comments »
 

Huh?Back in June we let you know that the ASCAP was suing AT&T for royalties every time a ringtone was played. Their reasoning was that playing a ringtone in public was a “Public Performance” of the music and AT&T owed them for those performances.

Luckily the federal judge hearing the case realized this was a idiotic argument and ruled that it does not constitute a public performance because carriers do not control when a ringtone plays or expect any revenue from the performance.

So what do you think? Is this whole argument from the music industry yet another cry for help or is it actually a valid argument?

via Mashable

Please Share With A Friend!

This entry was posted on Monday, October 19th, 2009 and is filed under News.
Tags: , ,

If you enjoyed this article, make sure you subscribe to our RSS Feed to stay on top of the latest BlackBerry news you can use.

Previous Post: Air Canada Releases Free BlackBerry App »
Next Post: inPulse Working on Bluetooth Watch for BlackBerry? »

If you liked this article, you might find these interesting:

Latest Articles:

2 Comments to “Judge Rules Royalties for Public Performances of Ringtones is Sham

  1. Well at least one judge has his head on straight……

    But i’m sure we haven’t heard the end of the idiocy pertaining to this.

    Reply
  2. This was the right call. It’s no more of a public performance than having your stereo on in your car with the windows down. It is using (hopefully) legally obtained music for personal gain. Someone eavesdropping on your ringtone or stereo can’t possibly be considered a public performance.

    Reply

Subscribe without commenting

Leave a Reply

Save yourself some time by quickly logging in or registering

Note: Any comments are permitted only because the site owner is letting you post, and any comments will be removed for any reason at the absolute discretion of the site owner. FYI: Links will automatically be hyperlinked so there is no need to use HTML